Have you got your Vplates?

When I read this by Alexandra Adornetto, I wasn’t sure whether to laugh, cry, or wonder whether I’d woken up in 1950.  (I will try to put down some of the more naive comments to her youth, but Tony Abbott has no excuse.) 

All of my YA novels have dealt, to greater or lesser degree, with female sexuality, past and present – not least my most recently completed one, which deals with the ramifications of four girls making a deliberate decision to lose their virginity.  I have therefore had some cause to reflect on the complexities faced by young women and how they negotiate the tricky area of sexuality and desire.  In the process of writing the last novel, I took a quite extensive survey of my female friends and acquaintances on their first times, and was astonished at the sheer variety of experiences women have had – although they probably came down more on the negative side, regardless of who it was with, one night stand or just-married husband.  I was also astonished at the number of women whose first sexual experiences (not necessarily sex) were not at their own instigation, but were the result of predatory uncles, family friends, older brothers etc.  For us to be having a conversation about female sexuality, this vast and undiscussed underbelly of experience also needs to be taken into account. 

But I want to ask: why are we having this debate about virginity?  Why the focus on what young women are or aren’t doing?  Where is the discussion of young men’s behaviour – which to me would seem the more worrying?  Is it because girls are acing boys academically?  Is it because Julia Gillard scares the bejesus out of Tony Abbott?  Are girls going to be told to stay home and reproduce next?  And my goodness, don’t we have more important things to worry about?

This isn’t to say that sex can’t be dangerous territory for young women: Alexandra is on the money when she mentions the damage that can be done by mixing sex and alcohol, and the sexualisation of girls and women – which also reduces females to their bodies – is concerning to many commentators (thanks Cassandra for the link).  But it’s not enough to say to girls to just say no: it merely shifts the responsibility for the problem of our porn-obsessed, hypersexualised culture.  It would be far better for Alexandra and other young women to challenge the stereotypes they are confronted with: what do they say when boys of their acquaintance call someone slutty-mc-slut-slut?  Smile politely?  I hope not.

If I had any advice for young women and sex, it would be: do what you do when you want to do it.  If your peers equate your reputation with your level sexual activity, virginal or otherwise, go find different peers.  Equating a girl’s worth with her hymen is demeaning.  Actually, equating sex with penetration is a problem in itself – ask Bill Clinton.  What about questions of pleasure and desire?  It seems to be a no-go area in discussions of female sexuality. 

The only cheering thing about this whole debate is that Tony Abbott, presumably, would appear to approve of young lesbian women.  A silver lining, indeed.

And at least it turns out I may have written a topical novel for once. 

4 thoughts on “Have you got your Vplates?

  1. Anonymous

    The most hilarious thing about Alexandra’s article is the “being in a bar” and then, “Alexandra is 17…” Hopefully I am not the only one to pick that up!

    But yes I agree with you, Julia.

    Very interesting about the results of your interviews, my eye brows were raised at that.

    Amen: “Do what you do when you want to do it”.

    If everyone knew that and followed that, the world would be a better place.


  2. liliwilkinson

    The thing that really bothers me about the whole debate (and Alexandra’s piece in particular) is this underlying assumption that teenage girls don’t want to have sex, and that women in general don’t, and shouldn’t want to. That the only reason why people have sex is because men are pressuring women to do so.

    Virginity isn’t the gift. Sex is the gift, and it’s an ongoing one that is shared, which is much nicer than surrendering your hymen to someone for all eternity.


  3. Anonymous

    Have you got your Vplates?

    This is such an interesting debate, and I am very interested in your comments on it, Julia. I also find the focus on female virginity puzzling, and I dislike the idea of ‘giving it’ to someone as a ‘gift’. And I have also heard a disturbing number of dreadful ‘first time’ experiences, which is sad and scary and an indictment. How can this be addressed? It’s the way of our society to fragment things, whereas sexuality does not need to be something separate. How you treat yourself and others hopefully informs your sexual behaviour, too. I respected Alexandra Adornetto’s desire to wait until she feels somewhat safe in a relationship, and her expectation and desire for the other person to be there the next day seems modest and reasonable to me. There is no reason why random, casual sex can’t be as loving, honest and respectful, if not more so than longterm monogamous sex – but it often seems to be attached to notions of racking up sexual conquests etc. without the participants recognising the worth and humanity in each other. Nothing is guaranteed, but it is wise to have a fair idea of who you are doing it with simply because sexual encounters can have profound consequences, not just for you, but also for your partner(s). Cheers, Catherine.


  4. Anonymous

    V plates

    Losing one’s virginity in an ideal world, would be how you’d always dreamt it to be, But the reality now days, its probly going to be a hazy drunken fiasco at 18th Bday party that you snuck into as your only 15 and is more than likely to be severly disappointing and possibly repution invoking!! If girls are not affected by substance’s and know what they want, then thats fine, but we’ve all seen the one’s who have had to many, hopefully they learn from it but some seem to do it week in week out. Guys who take advantage of this, really need a to have a good hard think about their behavior as most of them ridicule,judge and avoid relationships with these girls, who’s only naive mistake and regret is being coerced by the aforementioned.



Leave a Reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s